Sitting Bulls lost horses – not so lost

Wernernokota 348

The latest issue of the Western Horseman magazine encloses the article “Sitting Bulls lost horses?” about the Nokota horses. At some part it is informative to the common reader even if it is full of contradictions and simple errors, but in a lame effort to reflect over contradictory opinions about the Nokota horse history to put the article on an edge, it just gets rude and unbalanced. The writer Ryan T Bell has, either in total lack of serious research or for some unknown reasons, totally missed out on everything worth telling about these wonderful horses.

It all boils down to the connection between the Native American horses and the Nokota horses. The history of the horses is amazingly fascinating and exciting, but the quarrel created by some scorned wannabe cowboys is somewhat tiresome and only makes the common reader confused.
Either the Nokota horses are descendants of Sitting Bulls horses or they are not, there is nothing in between, right? Propose it cannot yet be proven in a court of law, beyond reasonable doubt, that the Nokota horses are descendants of Sitting Bulls horses; it does not prove the opposite either. There is more than one written contemporary evidence that supports the claim that 250 of the horses which roamed the badlands indeed were Sitting Bulls horses, but there is no single evidence of any kind beyond bold talk that proves that every single one of these 250 horses was destroyed before anyone could pass on their genes.
It is therefore logical to state that it is 250 times more probable that the Nokota horses do descend from Sitting Bulls horses at some extent than that they do not. I would not go as far as to state that it makes the skeptics 250 times less intelligent, but it is tempting to make such an analogy. Whether the truth is black, white or rather grey; the Nokota horse dresses well in all of them.
So instead of doing the right thing, by telling the readers about the great American wild horse from the northern plains who so trustfully, in spite of more than a century of persecution, puts its faith in us humans, the writer Ryan T Bell is picking on the only people brave enough to stand between the Nokota horses and their extinction.

Advertisements

12 thoughts on “Sitting Bulls lost horses – not so lost

      • when we went to the Powwow a few years ago up in Montana – the one sight that astounded me was the little kids bareback on horses with just a halter.

        I expect their horses wandered all about when there were no fences.

        Like

        • there’s always a couple who walk the fence, or want to explore.

          I read a story by Ben Greene, an old cowboy and veterinarian who used to go down to Mexico to buy horses to sell to the army. Some of the Indian tribes down there would have fine horses. The horses would be out grazing, and they had young girl runners who would chase them in on foot. Why young girls? Because the boys would always get impatient and distracted.

          Like

  1. i really like your conclusion, and am very glad that more people like yourself are stepping up to stand with the Kuntz Family between the Nokota horses and extinction! Thank you!

    Like

  2. You are doing a wonderful service for us all, preserving these beautiful ancient wild horses. Whether they were Sitting Bulls….or someone else’s …..they are wonderful and were here long before the settlers! They deserve respect

    Like

  3. We all go back to Adam and Eve! The statement they wrote about my dad Tom Tescher is pure fiction. He did not say that!!!

    Like

    • Sorry to hear that you feel your Dad got misrepresented in the article. Which one of the statements they wrote about are you referring to?

      I, too, read the article and it seems like the writer of the article got a fair few things confused from what I’ve heard from people interviewed and what I know myself of the people around the Nokota horses. Maybe it was all a mistake from the writer’s side but seeing from how much in today’s media is about spurring intruiges and fights I moreso feel that it might have been intentional. I find it pretty tiresome that so much energy is put into making people suspicious of each other rather than seeing the good in each other.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s